Comments on: A Missionary Travels: Visualising John William Arthur’s Movements Around And Between Scotland and Kenya c.1906-1938.  http://transnationalhistory.net/mvth/a-missionary-travels-visualising-john-william-arthurs-movements-around-and-between-scotland-and-kenya-c-1906-1938/ Connecting History, Space and Digital Tools Tue, 10 Jun 2014 16:47:30 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=4.0.1 By: Georgina Rannard http://transnationalhistory.net/mvth/a-missionary-travels-visualising-john-william-arthurs-movements-around-and-between-scotland-and-kenya-c-1906-1938/#comment-21 Thu, 05 Jun 2014 18:33:23 +0000 http://transnationalhistory.net/mvth/?p=75#comment-21 Hi Tom,
Thanks for providing this material, it’s very interesting. I plan to read through your transcripts when my internet connectivity allows me….hopefully later this evening.

On my first reading, your quotation from Lefebvre, White, ‘Movement is a productive process’ stood out as something that highlights what you, I, and I think Alexander are trying to visualise. We all already have the travel routes of people or information across borders (John Aruther, geographical knowledge/maps, and the Gundi tobacco), and we are aware that there is something significant about the process of movement and what happens both to the object/person, and perhaps also the environment in your case (although I am wondering whether your focus is on John Arthur as affected by movement or the space he travels in affected by him?). A first tool for looking at this, as you pointed out, is actually visualiing (rather than textually describing) their movements. I wonder then what it is possible to do with these images – will they create insights that we previously have not been able to access, or they are purely didactic? (In some ways this links to a question I alluded to regarding identification of networks – what can identification of networks tell us beyond their existence?).. You alluded to this I think in your comment ‘showing the inherent mobility of missionaries’.

]]>
By: Tom Cunningham http://transnationalhistory.net/mvth/a-missionary-travels-visualising-john-william-arthurs-movements-around-and-between-scotland-and-kenya-c-1906-1938/#comment-20 Thu, 05 Jun 2014 11:23:16 +0000 http://transnationalhistory.net/mvth/?p=75#comment-20 Dear Rolf, Thanks for taking the time to reply to my comment. We will have much to discuss on Sunday

]]>
By: Ananieva & Haaser http://transnationalhistory.net/mvth/a-missionary-travels-visualising-john-william-arthurs-movements-around-and-between-scotland-and-kenya-c-1906-1938/#comment-15 Tue, 03 Jun 2014 17:58:46 +0000 http://transnationalhistory.net/mvth/?p=75#comment-15 Dear Tom,
thanks for your comment. I must admit that we have not given much thought on the question of qualitative change of objects during transfer movements yet. Changes in the quality of media news in the flow from one country to another are much easier to trace.
Some thoughts after having read your abstract: Autobiographical sketches and travel accounts are very frequent in the journals and magazines we concentrate on in our Tuebingen project. I’m afraid we have not yet come to a convincing solution of how to visualize and/or map this sector of our research field. It looks as if we had an overlapping interest in this respect?
Rolf

]]>